|
|
BATTLESTAR |
|
|
|
BLOG |
|
Sunday, August 14, 2005The FarmCritics complained about the original Battlestar Galactica series because none of the space physics made any sense. They fixed those problems in the new series, with plausible explanations for how the fleet gets from place to place. The problem with the new series is that the Cylons who look like humans storyline makes no sense! In “The Farm,” we learn that they Cylons are trying to use captured humans to make babies. Why? If the Cylons are able to create life that is so identical to humans they it’s impossible to tell them apart, even with all of Galactica’s advanced medical equipment, why can’t they have babies? It just doesn’t make any sense. Meanwhile, as someone who left a comment here predicted, Roslin left for Kobol and the Galactica will be forced to follow her because 24 ships went along with her. There are two possibilities here. Either she will turn out to be right, or she will turn out to be wrong. I’m sure hoping that she turns out to be wrong and the trip to Kobol is a big dead end. Because I really can’t stand her. And I really like Commander Adama who is the coolest space captain ever, even more so than Commander Adama from the original Battlestar Galactica. * * * And apologies for not writing about last week’s episode, “Resistance.” I loved the scene where Baltar got Sharon to tell him how many Cylons are embedded with the fleet by injecting Chief Tyrol with poison and withholding the antidote until he spoke up. Did Baltar really want to know? Or was he just curious to see if Sharon really loved the Chief?
Comments:
I think that the reason Cylons can't have babies is kind of like how mules are unable to procreate; you can only make another mule with a donkey and a horse. In this way, Cylons need humans to make another Cylon, and can't procreate independantly. Or some junk like that. I'm no expert at this, that's just my theory.
The Cylons let a lot of stuff happen that may seem contradictory to the whole "destroy all humans" ethos because of this firm belief that everything that is happening "is written" and certain characters have a destiny to fulfill. Very determinist. Actually, what you'd expect from a machine, if you want to get all philosophical...
Remember the Galactica mythos in both versions borrows heavily from the Jewish mythos - 12 tribes and promised land and all that - so the Cylons employ "Centurians" a la the Romans, who eventually came to believe in "one true God" and colonised the world with Catholicism... The procreation bit is a stretch I agree, because they used to be indistinguishable from humans and yet here's this gaping big flaw now in their reproductive system that somehow humanity's best scientists (left alive) missed?
regarding what anoymous said about the scientist missing the "human"cylons inability to procreate...theory...even us humans cannot tell who can and who cant till you go to trying and come up empty. sometimes it's male, sometimes it's female...unless the test are specifically designed to look in those areas, why wouldn't it show up. and also it may just mimick a human condition of some of our own infertile males & females...just throwing that out there.
btw...hated the old battlestar, love this one...adama was always "ben cartwright"...sorry
I agree something's missing where procreation is concerned. Yet the writers have been very methodical about making twists and turns. "They have a plan". Could it be that taking humans to the point of extinction, then trapping them emotionally into being willing parents of mixed species is part of it.
Post a Comment
|